Photo of Richard Ansara - Attorney at Law
Call or Text Us 24/7 at (954) 761-4011
REQUEST A FREE CONSULTATION
Richard Ansara Attorney at Law

By

As a Fort Lauderdale criminal defense attorney who regularly represents clients facing domestic violence charges, I often hear variations of the same anguished statement: “I didn’t mean to hurt them.” It’s a deeply human reaction—the immediate regret following an incident that has spiraled out of control, leaving both the alleged victim and the accused dealing with serious legal consequences.Broward domestic violence defense lawyer

This statement reveals something important about how many people understand their own actions. They recognize that harm occurred, but they genuinely didn’t intend for things to escalate to that point. Perhaps an argument became heated, emotions ran high, and physical contact occurred in the chaos. Perhaps they were trying to prevent their partner from leaving during an argument, or they grabbed something without thinking and it made contact with someone else.

The critical legal question becomes: Does lack of intent to cause harm provide a valid defense to domestic violence charges? As a Broward domestic violence defense lawyer, I will always be honest with my clients about the reality of their situation. And the fact is, while  a defendant’s intent is a key element in many criminal charges (including domestic violence offenses), that doesn’t necessarily mean lack of intent to cause harm will be the basis for the best defense.

Understanding Florida’s Domestic Violence Statute

Under Florida Statute § 741.28, “domestic violence” is defined as any assault, aggravated assault, battery, aggravated battery, sexual assault, sexual battery, stalking, aggravated stalking, kidnapping, false imprisonment, or any criminal offense resulting in physical injury or death of one family or household member by another family or household member.

Notice what this definition does—it incorporates other criminal offenses, most commonly battery, into the domestic violence framework when those offenses occur between family or household members. This means we must understand both the underlying criminal charge (like battery) and how the domestic relationship aspect affects the case.

Family or household members include spouses, former spouses, persons related by blood or marriage, persons currently living together or who have lived together in the past as a family, and persons who share a child in common, regardless of whether they were ever married.

Why Intent (Mens Rea) Matters in Criminal Law

In criminal law, mens rea — Latin for “guilty mind” — refers to the mental state or intent required to establish criminal liability. Different crimes require different levels of intent, and this distinction is fundamental to our justice system. It’s why we differentiate between murder and manslaughter, between theft and accidentally taking someone else’s property.

For battery charges, which form the foundation of most domestic violence cases in Florida, intent is indeed a required element. Under Florida Statute § 784.03, battery occurs when a person:

  1. Actually and intentionally touches or strikes another person against their will, or
  2. Intentionally causes bodily harm to another person

The word “intentionally” appears prominently in this statute, which might initially seem encouraging if you’re saying “I didn’t mean to hurt them.” However — and this is crucial — the intent requirement is more nuanced than most people realize.

The Critical Distinction: Intent to Touch vs. Intent to Harm

Here’s where the law becomes counterintuitive for many defendants: the prosecution does not need to prove you intended to cause harm or injury.

Florida courts have been clear on this point. For a battery conviction, the state only needs to establish that you intended the contact itself (the touching, striking, or grabbing) not that you intended for that contact to result in injury or harm. Florida courts have ruled the defendant need only intend to touch or strike a person without their consent. As such, the State is not required to show the defendant intended harm or injury.

This means that even if you genuinely didn’t mean for your partner to get hurt, if you intentionally:

  • Grabbed their arm to stop them from leaving
  • Pushed them during an argument
  • Threw an object in their direction
  • Made any physical contact that they did not consent to

…you may have committed battery, even if injury wasn’t your goal and even if no significant injury occurred.

The touching must be intentional and against the other person’s will. Truly accidental contact — like bumping into someone in a doorway — doesn’t constitute battery. But once you cross the line into intentional, non-consensual touching, the fact that you didn’t want anyone to get hurt may not be a complete defense.

Why “I Didn’t Mean to Hurt Them” Usually Isn’t Enough

When clients tell me they didn’t mean to cause harm, they’re often making what lawyers call a “specific intent” argument. They’re saying they didn’t specifically intend the harmful result. Unfortunately, battery is what we call a “general intent” crime. This means the prosecution only needs to prove you intended to commit the act (the touching) that resulted in the offense, not that you intended all of the consequences that flowed from that act.criminal defense lawyer Fort Lauderdale

Consider this common scenario: During a heated argument, you grab your partner’s wrist to prevent them from walking away. You don’t intend to hurt them; you just want them to stay and finish the conversation. But the grab is forceful enough to leave a bruise. Your partner calls the police.

In this situation, saying, “I didn’t mean to hurt them,” actually hurts your defense. It acknowledges the intentional touching but focuses on your lack of intent regarding the injury. However, because you intentionally grabbed their wrist against their will, you’ve satisfied the legal definition of battery. The bruise becomes evidence of the offense, not a required element that you had to specifically intend.

That’s why your Broward domestic violence defense lawyer may advise you against arguing a lack of intent to cause harm, as that alone is rarely a winning strategy in these cases.

So What Defense Strategies Actually Work?

The good news is that experienced domestic violence defense attorneys have numerous strategic approaches that may be more effective than simply arguing you didn’t mean to cause harm. The right strategy depends on the specific facts of your case, the available evidence, and your goals (whether that’s complete dismissal, reduced charges, or minimizing consequences). Continue reading

By

South Florida’s waters offer some of the best fishing in the world, attracting anglers from across the globe to Fort Lauderdale and Broward County. Whether you’re casting a line from the beach, pier fishing, or enjoying a day on your boat, it’s easy to get caught up in the excitement of a great catch—and inadvertently violate Florida’s complex fishing regulations. What many anglers don’t realize is that seemingly minor mistakes can result in criminal charges with serious consequences.Broward FWC violations attorney

If you’ve received a citation from the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) for alleged fishing violations, understanding your rights and defenses is crucial. As Broward FWC violations attorneys can explain, these aren’t just “tickets”—they’re criminal charges that can impact your record, your wallet, and your future fishing privileges.

Understanding Florida’s Fishing Regulations

Continue reading

By

If you’re facing domestic violence charges in Fort Lauderdale, you might be focused solely on avoiding jail time or probation. While these immediate penalties are certainly serious, the collateral consequences of a domestic violence conviction can affect your life for years—or even decades—after your case concludes. Understanding these hidden penalties is crucial when deciding whether to hire a Fort Lauderdale criminal defense attorney or attempt to represent yourself.Fort Lauderdale criminal defense lawyer

Loss of Gun Rights: A Federal Prohibition

One of the most significant collateral consequences of a domestic violence conviction is the permanent loss of your Second Amendment rights. Under federal law, specifically the Lautenberg Amendment to the Gun Control Act, anyone convicted of a misdemeanor crime of domestic violence is prohibited from possessing firearms or ammunition for life. This isn’t just a Florida restriction—it’s a federal prohibition that follows you nationwide.

For law enforcement officers, military personnel, or security professionals in Fort Lauderdale, this consequence alone can end a career. Even recreational gun owners face a lifetime ban with no possibility of restoration.

A Fort Lauderdale criminal defense attorney can explore alternatives like pretrial diversion programs or negotiate reduced charges that don’t trigger this federal firearm prohibition.

Professional Licensing Complications

Florida’s professional licensing boards take domestic violence convictions seriously. Under Florida Statute § 741.30, domestic violence is defined as any assault, battery, or other criminal offense resulting in physical injury or death between family or household members. A conviction under this statute can jeopardize professional licenses for:

  • Healthcare workers (doctors, nurses, EMTs)
  • Attorneys and legal professionals
  • Real estate agents and brokers
  • Teachers and educators
  • Financial professionals and accountants

Many licensing boards consider domestic violence a crime of moral turpitude, which can result in license suspension, revocation, or denial of renewal. Even if you avoid jail time, losing your professional license could devastate your career and earning potential. At The Ansara Law Firm, we understand how to present your case in a way that protects not just your freedom, but your livelihood.

Immigration Consequences for Non-Citizens

Continue reading

By

If you’ve been charged with a crime in Fort Lauderdale, you’ll likely hear the term “plea bargain” early and often. Prosecutors may offer one. Your criminal defense attorney will discuss whether you should accept it. Friends or family might advise you to “just take the deal.” But what exactly is a plea bargain, and how do you know if accepting one is the right decision for your case?Fort Lauderdale criminal lawyer plea bargain

As a longtime Fort Lauderdale criminal defense lawyer, I’ve negotiated hundreds of plea agreements over the years. Understanding how plea bargains work, why they’re so prevalent in our criminal justice system, and when they serve your interests (versus when they don’t) is crucial to making an informed decision about your future.

What Is a Plea Bargain?

A plea bargain—also called a plea agreement or plea deal—is a negotiated agreement between the defendant and the prosecutor in which the defendant agrees to plead guilty or no contest to criminal charges in exchange for some form of concession from the state.

These concessions typically take one of several forms:

  • Charge Bargaining: The prosecutor agrees to reduce the charges to something less serious. For example, a felony battery charge might be reduced to misdemeanor battery, or a DUI might be reduced to reckless driving.
  • Sentence Bargaining: The defendant pleads guilty to the original charge, but the prosecutor agrees to recommend a specific, more lenient sentence to the judge. This might include reduced jail time, probation instead of incarceration, or participation in a diversion program.
  • Count Bargaining: When a defendant faces multiple charges, the prosecutor agrees to dismiss some counts in exchange for a guilty plea to others.

Under Florida Rule of Criminal Procedure 3.171, plea agreements must be disclosed in open court, and the judge must determine that the plea is entered voluntarily and intelligently. The judge isn’t bound by the sentencing recommendations in the plea agreement, though most judges will follow them unless there are compelling reasons not to.

It’s important to understand that when you enter a plea bargain, you’re waiving significant constitutional rights, including:

  • Your right to a trial by jury
  • Your right to confront witnesses against you
  • Your right to remain silent
  • Your right to require the state to prove your guilt beyond a reasonable doubt

This is why the decision to accept a plea bargain should never be taken lightly or made without fully understanding what you’re giving up and what you’re getting in return.

Why Are Plea Bargains So Common in Florida?

If you look at the statistics, the prevalence of plea bargains is staggering. Approximately 90-95% of criminal cases in Florida—and across the United States—are resolved through plea agreements rather than trials. This isn’t an accident. There are systemic reasons why plea bargains dominate our criminal justice system.

Court Resources Are Limited

The reality is that our criminal justice system would collapse if every case went to trial. Courts, prosecutors, and public defenders are managing enormous caseloads. In Broward County alone, tens of thousands of criminal cases are filed each year. If even a fraction of these cases proceeded to trial, the court system would grind to a halt.

Trials require significant time and resources. What might take thirty minutes to resolve with a plea agreement could require days or weeks of trial time, including jury selection, witness testimony, legal arguments, and deliberations. From a practical standpoint, the system depends on plea bargains to function.

Both Sides Face Uncertainty

Trials are inherently unpredictable. No matter how strong the prosecution’s case appears, there’s always a chance a jury will acquit. No matter how compelling your defense, there’s always a risk of conviction. A plea bargain removes this uncertainty for both parties, and gives both sides a measure of control over the outcome.

For prosecutors, a plea agreement guarantees a conviction without the risk of acquittal. For defendants, it typically provides a more predictable and often more lenient outcome than what they might face if they take their chances and end up convicted at trial.

Prosecutors Have Charging Discretion

Florida law gives prosecutors broad discretion in how they charge cases. Under Florida Statute § 27.02, the state attorney has the authority to determine what charges to file, what charges to pursue, and what plea offers to make. This discretion is a powerful tool that drives the plea bargaining process.

Prosecutors know they can charge aggressively and then offer reductions as an incentive to plead. They can file multiple counts arising from the same incident and offer to dismiss some in exchange for a guilty plea. This leverage is built into the system.

How Plea Bargains Can Benefit Criminal Defendants

For many Broward County criminal case defendants, accepting a well-negotiated plea bargain is the best possible outcome. Here’s why:plea bargain Fort Lauderdale criminal defense lawyer

Reduced Charges and Penalties

The most obvious benefit is the potential for reduced charges and lighter sentences. A felony conviction carries far more severe consequences than a misdemeanor—longer potential prison sentences, the loss of civil rights (including voting and firearm possession), and a greater stigma that can affect employment and housing for years to come.

Consider a defendant charged with felony aggravated assault. Through plea negotiations, their attorney might get the charge reduced to misdemeanor simple assault. Instead of facing up to five years in prison and a permanent felony record, the defendant might receive probation and maintain a cleaner record. That’s a life-changing difference.

Certainty and Control

When you accept a plea bargain, you know exactly what you’re getting. You know what you’re pleading to, what the sentence will be (or what the prosecutor will recommend), and what conditions you’ll need to satisfy. This certainty can be invaluable, particularly when you’re facing serious charges with substantial prison time.

Trials, by contrast, are unpredictable. Juries can be swayed by factors that have nothing to do with the evidence. Judges have discretion in sentencing. A plea bargain lets you take control of your outcome rather than leaving it in the hands of twelve strangers.

Avoiding Mandatory Minimums

Florida has numerous mandatory minimum sentencing laws, particularly for offenses involving firearms, drug trafficking, and certain violent crimes. These mandatory minimums tie the judge’s hands—even if the judge wants to show leniency, they legally cannot sentence below the minimum.

Through plea negotiations, an experienced attorney can sometimes get charges reduced to offenses without mandatory minimums, giving the judge discretion to impose a more reasonable sentence based on your individual circumstances.

Saving Time and Money

Trials are expensive. If you’re paying for a private attorney, trial preparation and courtroom time can cost thousands or tens of thousands of dollars. Even with a public defender, the process consumes months of your life, including multiple court appearances, depositions, and the stress of an uncertain outcome.

A plea bargain resolves your case more quickly and with less financial burden, allowing you to move forward with your life sooner.

Reducing Collateral Consequences

Beyond the direct criminal penalties, convictions carry collateral consequences—effects on employment, professional licenses, immigration status, child custody, housing, and more. A reduced charge through a plea bargain can minimize these collateral consequences significantly.

For example, certain crimes involve “moral turpitude” that can trigger deportation for non-citizens. An attorney familiar with immigration consequences might negotiate a plea to a charge that doesn’t implicate immigration law, protecting your ability to remain in the country.

Access to Diversion Programs

Many plea agreements involve diversion programs—alternatives to traditional prosecution that allow you to avoid a conviction altogether if you successfully complete certain requirements. In Broward County, we have drug court, mental health court, veterans court, and various pretrial diversion programs.

These programs typically require you to enter a plea agreement, complete treatment or community service, and stay out of trouble for a specified period. If you succeed, the charges are dismissed. This is often the best possible outcome—avoiding conviction entirely while addressing underlying issues like substance abuse.

When a Plea Bargain Might NOT Be the Best Choicecriminal defense lawyer Fort Lauderdale

Despite their prevalence, plea bargains aren’t always the right answer. There are situations where rejecting a plea offer and going to trial is the better strategic decision. A skilled criminal defense lawyer can help you identify when walking away from a plea deal is actually the smartest move. This can can include:

When You’re Actually Innocent

This might seem obvious, but it’s worth stating clearly: if you didn’t commit the crime and the evidence is weak, you shouldn’t plead guilty just to avoid the stress of trial. I’ve seen cases where the prosecution’s evidence is so thin that they really have no chance of conviction. In those cases, we take it to trial.

The problem is that innocent people sometimes accept plea deals out of fear or pressure. They’re told that if they lose at trial, they’ll face much harsher penalties. This creates enormous pressure to accept guilt for something they didn’t do. (This is not to say innocent people might sometimes be better served with a plea deal.) It really just depends. An experienced criminal defense attorney can help you objectively assess the strength of the prosecution’s case and whether you have a realistic chance of charge dismissal or acquittal.

When the Plea Offer Isn’t Significantly Better Than Trial

Continue reading

By

As a criminal defense attorney practicing in Fort Lauderdale, I’ve received more than a few panicked phone calls that start: “I missed my court date. What do I do now?” The anxiety in their voices is palpable, and for good reason: missing a court appearance can transform a manageable legal situation into a potential crisis.

But the good news is that with the help of proper legal counsel, there are steps you can take to minimize the fallout.missed court date Broward County defense lawyer

Understanding Court Appearances in Florida

First, let’s clarify what we’re talking about. Court appearances in Florida aren’t just for serious felonies. You might be required to appear for a wide range of matters, including:

  • Traffic violations beyond simple speeding tickets (DUI, reckless driving, driving with a suspended license)
  • Misdemeanors like petit theft, battery, disorderly conduct, or possession of marijuana
  • Felonies ranging from drug possession to aggravated assault
  • Probation violation hearings
  • Pretrial conferences and status hearings
  • Arraignments where you enter your initial plea

Some people assume that minor charges mean they can skip court without serious consequences. This is a dangerous misconception. Whether you’re facing a misdemeanor trespassing charge or a third-degree felony, the court expects you to appear when ordered.

What the Law Says: Florida Statute § 843.15

Florida doesn’t take missed court dates lightly. Under Florida Statute § 843.15, failure to appear for a court date in a criminal case is itself a separate crime. Here’s what you need to know:

If you were released on bail or your own recognizance and fail to appear for a felony charge, you’ve committed a third-degree felony—punishable by up to five years in prison. If you fail to appear for a misdemeanor charge, you’ve committed a first-degree misdemeanor—punishable by up to one year in jail.

Per F.S. 901.31, if you fail to obey a written promise to appear, you can be fined up to the maximum fine and/or sentenced to the maximum sentence of imprisonment on the principle charge – regardless of the disposition of the original charge.

Per F.S. 901.11, if you fail to appear as commanded by a summons without good cause, that’s considered an indirect criminal contempt of court, and can be punished by a $100 fine. Beyond that, the judge can issue a warrant for your arrest.

What Happens Immediately After You Miss Court

The moment you fail to appear, several things typically happen in quick succession:

1. The Judge Issues a Bench Warrant

Within minutes of your absence, the judge will likely issue a bench warrant for your arrest. As a Fort Lauderdale criminal defense lawyer can explain, this isn’t a “we’ll get around to it eventually” situation. The warrant goes into the system immediately, meaning any interaction with law enforcement—a traffic stop, an airport security check, even a routine identification check—can result in your arrest on the spot.

2. Your Bond May Be Revoked or Forfeited

If you posted bail, you’ve likely violated the conditions of your release. The court may forfeit your bond, meaning you or your bondsman loses that money. When you’re eventually taken into custody, the judge may set a higher bond or deny bond altogether, viewing you as a flight risk.

3. Additional Charges May Be Filed

As mentioned above, the State Attorney’s office can—and often does—file additional charges under Florida Statute § 843.15 for failure to appear. Now you’re defending against both your original charge and a new criminal offense.

4. Your Case Proceeds Without You

In some traffic and misdemeanor cases, the court may proceed in your absence, potentially entering a guilty verdict or judgment against you (known as a “default judgment”) without hearing your side of the story.

Why Do People Miss Court? (And Why It Doesn’t Matter)Fort Lauderdale criminal defense attorney

Over the years, I’ve heard every reason imaginable:

  • “I forgot the date”
  • “My car broke down”
  • “I was in the hospital”
  • “I had to work and couldn’t get time off”
  • “I was caring for a sick family member”
  • “I was too scared to go”
  • “I thought my attorney was handling it”
  • “I never received the notice”

Some of these reasons are understandable. Some are even legitimate emergencies. But here’s the hard truth: the court doesn’t automatically care why you missed your appearance. The burden is on you to notify the court beforehand if you have a legitimate conflict, or to remedy the situation immediately afterward.

The legal system operates on the principle that you were given notice and an opportunity to appear. Whether your reasons were valid or not, you still need to take specific legal steps to address the failure to appear—and hoping the problem goes away is not a strategy. The fact that your original legal problem is not further compounded makes it all the more important to hire a criminal defense lawyer right away to help you navigate the system from here.

The Ripple Effects You Might Not Expect

Beyond the immediate legal consequences, a missed court date can affect your life in ways you might not anticipate:

  • Employment complications: A warrant shows up on background checks, potentially costing you job opportunities or even your current position.
  • Housing issues: Landlords routinely run background checks. An outstanding warrant is a red flag.
  • Driver’s license suspension: For many offenses, the DMV will suspend your license when you fail to appear.
  • Immigration consequences: For non-citizens, a failure to appear can have devastating effects on immigration status, pending applications, or future admissibility.
  • Constant anxiety: Living with an outstanding warrant means constantly looking over your shoulder, unable to travel freely or live normally.

What You Should Do Right Now

If you’ve missed a court date, time is not on your side. Here’s what you need to do:

1. Don’t Ignore It

The worst thing you can do is nothing. The warrant won’t disappear. The charges won’t go away. The longer you wait, the worse your situation becomes and the less sympathy the court will have when you finally address it.

2. Contact a Criminal Defense Attorney Immediately

This is not a DIY situation. Before you do anything else—before you call the court, before you turn yourself in, before you try to explain what happened—call an experienced criminal defense lawyer.

Why? Because how you handle the next steps can mean the difference between a quick resolution and months of additional legal problems.

3. Do NOT Turn Yourself In Without Legal Representation

Many people think they should just go to the courthouse or police station and turn themselves in. While the impulse is understandable, doing this without an attorney is a mistake. Once you’re in custody, you’ve lost leverage and options.

How a Criminal Defense Attorney Can Help

Continue reading

By

Fort Lauderdale DUI arrest lawyerGetting arrested for DUI in Broward County can be a frightening experience. Your mind races with questions: Will I lose my license? Can I keep my job? What happens next? As a Fort Lauderdale criminal defense attorney who has represented countless DUI clients, I can tell that worry is completely normal – but spiraling won’t help. But what you do in the first 24 hours after your arrest can impact the outcome of your case.

The 10-Day Window: Your License Is at Immediate Risk

Here’s what most people don’t realize when they’re released from jail: the clock is already ticking on your driver’s license. Under Florida Statute 322.2615, you have only 10 days from the date of your arrest to request a formal review hearing with the Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles (DHSMV). Miss this deadline, and your license will be automatically suspended.

This administrative suspension is completely separate from any criminal charges you’re facing. Even if you’re ultimately found not guilty in criminal court, failing to request this hearing within 10 days means losing your driving privileges. In Broward County, where public transportation is limited and most people depend on their vehicles for work, this can be devastating.

During those first 24 hours, one of your top priorities should be contacting an experienced DUI attorney who can immediately request this formal review hearing on your behalf. The hearing gives you an opportunity to challenge the suspension and, in many cases, obtain a hardship license that allows you to drive for work and other essential purposes.

Protect Your Right to Remain Silent

In the moments or hours following your release, you may feel compelled to explain yourself—to the arresting officer who calls with follow-up questions, to investigators, or even to friends and family on social media. Don’t.

Anything you say can be used against you in court. That social media post about “only having two beers” or your detailed explanation to a friend via text message can become evidence for the prosecution. It doesn’t matter if your social media page is private or the person your texting is your best friend. These can be accessed via subpoena. Law enforcement officers are trained to build cases, and seemingly casual conversations can provide them with ammunition.

You have a Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination. Exercise it. Politely decline to answer questions without your attorney present. This isn’t about appearing guilty—it’s about protecting your constitutional rights.

Document Everything You Remember

While you shouldn’t discuss your case with others, you should write down everything you remember about your arrest while the details are fresh. Your attorney will need this information to build your defense.

Document the following:

  • Where you were coming from and where you were going
  • What you ate and drank that evening (including times and quantities)
  • The reason you were pulled over
  • Everything the officer said and did during the stop
  • The field sobriety tests administered and any physical conditions that might have affected your performance (injuries, medical conditions, footwear, road conditions, weather)
  • Whether you were read Miranda rights and when
  • The conditions at the breath test facility
  • Any witnesses who were present

Don’t rely on your memory weeks or months from now. Create a detailed timeline as soon as possible — while these facts are still clear in your mind. If you haven’t already met with your attorney, have this information ready when you do.

Secure Evidence and Witnesses

Continue reading

By

When emotions run high in domestic disputes, situations can escalate quickly from verbal arguments to physical confrontations. If you’ve been arrested for domestic violence in Florida after defending yourself from an attack by a partner or family member, you may be wondering whether self-defense can be used as a legal defense in your case. The answer is nuanced, but yes—self-defense can potentially be used in Florida domestic violence cases under specific circumstances.Fort Lauderdale self-defense lawyer

Understanding Florida’s Self-Defense Laws

Florida’s self-defense statutes are among the most comprehensive in the nation, including the well-known “Stand Your Ground” law. The primary law governing self-defense in Florida is F.S. § 776.012, which establishes when a person is justified in using force to protect themselves or others.

Under this statute, a person is justified in using or threatening to use non-deadly force if they reasonably believe such force is necessary to defend themselves against another person’s imminent use of unlawful force. For deadly force, the standard is higher—it must be reasonably believed to be necessary to prevent imminent death or great bodily harm.

The Unique Challenges of Self-Defense in Domestic Violence Cases

While self-defense is a recognized legal principle in Florida, asserting this defense in domestic violence cases presents unique challenges that defendants and their attorneys must carefully navigate.

The “He Said, She Said” Problem

Domestic violence incidents typically occur in private settings without independent witnesses. This creates what legal professionals often refer to as a “he said, she said” situation. Law enforcement officers arriving at the scene must make quick determinations based on limited information, often relying on visible injuries, the demeanor of the parties involved, and statements made at the scene.

Unfortunately, these initial assessments don’t always capture the full picture of what transpired. The person who initiated the violence may not show visible injuries, while the person who defended themselves may have caused more apparent harm in their efforts to protect themselves.

Societal and Legal Bias

Florida courts and law enforcement are rightfully sympathetic to victims of domestic violence, particularly given the serious nature of domestic abuse and its prevalence in our society. However, this sympathy can sometimes create an environment where self-defense claims are viewed with skepticism, especially when they come from defendants who caused visible injury to their alleged victims.

The Burden of Proof

The key to this defense, however, is being able to provide evidence of the imminent threat to prove that your actions were justified. This is particularly challenging in domestic violence cases where evidence may be limited and emotions are high.

Essential Elements of a Self-Defense Claim

To successfully assert self-defense in a Florida domestic violence case, several critical elements must be established:

1. Imminent Threat of Harm

The threat must be immediate and real, not speculative or based on future harm. You cannot claim self-defense against a threat that might materialize later or in response to verbal threats alone, unless those threats are accompanied by actions that create a reasonable fear of imminent physical harm.

2. Reasonable Belief of Necessity

Your belief that force was necessary to protect yourself must be reasonable under the circumstances. This is evaluated from the perspective of a reasonable person in your situation, considering factors such as the size and strength of the parties involved, any weapons present, and the history of violence in the relationship.

3. Proportional Response

The force used in self-defense must be proportional to the threat faced. You cannot use deadly force in response to a minor threat of non-deadly force. The response must be reasonable given the nature and severity of the threat.

4. No Provocation

Under Section 776.041, Florida Statutes, self-defense is not available where the defendant initially provoked the violence. If you started the physical confrontation or provoked the violence through your actions, claiming self-defense becomes much more difficult, though not impossible under certain circumstances.

Florida Statute § 776.041: When Self-Defense Is Limited

It’s crucial to understand that Florida Statute § 776.041 limits the availability of self-defense claims when the defendant provoked the violence. However, even if you initially provoked the confrontation, you may still be able to claim self-defense if: Continue reading

By

If you’ve been arrested for DUI in Broward County, you’re probably feeling overwhelmed, scared, and unsure about what happens next. A DUI arrest can turn your world upside down in an instant. Here’s what it’s important to remember in this moment: you have rights, you have options, and with the right legal representation, you can navigate this challenging situation successfully.Broward DUI defense lawyer

The Stakes Are Higher Than You Think

As a longtime Fort Lauderdale DUI lawyer, I’ll be straight with you: Florida doesn’t mess around when it comes to DUI charges. Under Florida Statute 316.193, even a first-time DUI conviction can result in serious consequences that will follow you for years. We’re talking about potential jail time, hefty fines, license suspension, and mandatory DUI school.

Beyond that, a DUI conviction becomes part of your permanent criminal record. This means it can show up on background checks for jobs, housing applications, professional licenses, and even volunteer opportunities. In today’s digital age, that conviction can haunt you long after you’ve paid your debt to society.

Why Broward County DUI Cases Require Local Expertise

Something many people don’t realize is that not all DUI attorneys are created equal, especially when it comes to handling cases in Broward County. The legal landscape here has its own unique characteristics that require specific knowledge and experience.

Broward County has multiple courthouse locations, each with different judges, prosecutors, and local procedures. The judge who might be lenient in one courthouse could be a stickler for maximum penalties in another. An experienced local DUI attorney knows these nuances and can use this knowledge to your advantage.

Our local law enforcement agencies – from the Fort Lauderdale Police Department to the Broward Sheriff’s Office – each have their own protocols for DUI arrests. They use different breathalyzer machines, have different training procedures, and even different policies for conducting field sobriety tests. An attorney who regularly practices in Broward County understands these systems inside and out.

The Science Behind DUI Defense

One of the biggest misconceptions I hear is that if you blew over the legal limit, your case is hopeless. That’s simply not true. The science behind breath testing is more complex than most people realize, and there are numerous factors that can affect the accuracy of these tests.

Breathalyzer machines must be properly calibrated and maintained. The officer administering the test must be properly trained and follow specific protocols. Even your diet, medical conditions, or the time between your last drink and the test can significantly impact the results.

Field sobriety tests are even more subjective. These tests were designed for ideal conditions – flat, dry surfaces with good lighting and no distractions. How often does a roadside DUI stop meet these criteria? Factors like uneven pavement, flashing police lights, heavy traffic, weather conditions, or even your choice of shoes can affect your performance on these tests. Having a local Broward DUI defense lawyer who knows the area, the common blind spots of each department, and the defense strategies most likely to be successful in certain courts (and which won’t) can make all the difference in the outcome of your case.

Building a Strong Defense Strategy

Every DUI case is unique, and an experienced attorney knows how to identify the specific weaknesses in the prosecution’s case against you. Was the initial traffic stop justified? Did the officer have probable cause for the arrest? Were proper procedures followed during testing? Were your constitutional rights respected throughout the process?

These aren’t just technical legal questions – they’re the foundation of a strong defense. If law enforcement made mistakes or violated your rights, it could result in evidence being suppressed or even charges being dismissed entirely.

The Importance of Local Relationships Broward DUI defense lawyer

Over years of practicing DUI defense in Broward County, I’ve built relationships with prosecutors, judges, and court personnel. These relationships don’t guarantee outcomes, but they do help ensure that your case receives fair consideration and that plea negotiations happen in good faith.

I know which prosecutors are reasonable and which ones take hardline stances. I understand which judges appreciate thorough preparation and which ones prefer concise arguments. This local knowledge allows me to tailor our defense strategy to the specific individuals who will be handling your case.

Alternative Sentencing Options

Continue reading

By

If you’ve been charged with DUI in Florida, you’re likely feeling overwhelmed and uncertain about what comes next. As a Fort Lauderdale criminal defense attorney can explain, evidence from police bodycams and dashcams can play a crucial role in your defense – sometimes helping your case significantly, and other times presenting challenges we need to address strategically.Fort Lauderdale criminal defense lawyer

Understanding the Digital Evidence Landscape

In today’s law enforcement environment, nearly every DUI stop is recorded. Police vehicles are equipped with dashcams that capture the initial traffic stop, and officers wear bodycams that document their interactions with drivers. This footage becomes a permanent record of your encounter with law enforcement, and understanding how it can impact your case is essential.

How Video Evidence Can Help Your Defense

Sometimes, the video evidence captured by police can actually work to your advantage. Some of the ways that’s possible:

  • Challenging Officer Testimony

    • Video footage provides an objective record that can contradict inaccurate or embellished police testimony. If an officer claims you were stumbling severely, but the bodycam shows you walking steadily, this discrepancy can be powerful evidence in your favor.

  • Documenting Procedural Violations

    • Florida law requires officers to follow specific procedures during DUI investigations. Video evidence can reveal when these procedures weren’t followed properly. For example, if the footage shows an officer failed to properly administer field sobriety tests according to National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) standards, we can challenge the validity of those tests.

  • Revealing Environmental Factors

    • Dashcam and bodycam footage often capture important environmental conditions that may have affected field sobriety test performance – uneven pavement, poor lighting, heavy traffic, or adverse weather conditions. These factors can provide alternative explanations for poor performance on sobriety tests.

  • Demonstrating Sobriety Indicators

    • Sometimes the video actually shows you performing better than the officer’s report suggests. Clear speech, appropriate responses to questions, and steady movements captured on camera can contradict claims of obvious impairment.

When Video Evidence Presents ChallengesDUI Fort Lauderdale lawyer

  • Documenting Apparent Impairment

    • Unfortunately, video evidence can also capture behaviors that appear to support impairment charges. Slurred speech, unsteady movement, or poor performance on field sobriety tests recorded on camera can be compelling evidence for the prosecution.

  • Preserving Incriminating Statements

    • Bodycam footage preserves everything you say during the encounter. Admissions about drinking, statements about your condition, or responses that seem to indicate impairment can all be used against you in court.

In cases where an officer may have lacked reasonable suspicion to initiate the traffic stop in the first place, a Fort Lauderdale defense lawyer may have sufficient grounds to ask the court for a motion to suppress the footage. If the court grants it, it can’t be used to make a case against you. For some defendants, that can seriously undermine the prosecution’s case.

The Critical Importance of Remaining Silent

Something we as defense attorneys cannot stress enough: exercise your right to remain silent during any DUI investigation. This is especially important given the possibility that everything say is being recorded — and can be used against you in court.

Know that you are not required to: Continue reading

By

If you’re facing domestic violence charges in Fort Lauderdale involving a roommate, family member, or other household member who isn’t your intimate partner, you’re likely feeling confused and overwhelmed. Many people assume domestic violence laws only apply to spouses, boyfriends, or girlfriends, but Florida’s statutes can potentially cast a wider net. Understanding how these charges work—and how they differ from typical domestic violence cases—is crucial for protecting your rights and your future.Fort Lauderdale domestic violence attorney

Florida’s Expansive Definition of Domestic Violence

Under Florida Statute 741.28, domestic violence is defined as “any assault, aggravated assault, battery, aggravated battery, sexual assault, sexual battery, stalking, aggravated stalking, kidnapping, false imprisonment, or any criminal offense resulting in physical injury or death of one family or household member by another family or household member.”

The key phrase here is “family or household member,” which Florida law defines much more broadly than many people realize. According to Florida Statute 741.28(3), this includes:

  • Spouses, former spouses, and persons related by blood or marriage
  • Persons who are presently residing together as if a family or who have resided together in the past as if a family
  • Persons who are parents of a child in common regardless of whether they have been married or have resided together at any time
  • Persons who have resided together as a family unit, even if not related by blood or marriage

This last category is where many people find themselves unexpectedly caught up in domestic violence charges involving roommates, long-term houseguests, or other non-romantic cohabitants.

How Roommate and Family Member Cases Arise

The Roommate Scenario

Living with roommates, whether friends, acquaintances, or strangers, can create unique tensions. When disagreements escalate—over bills, cleanliness, noise, guests, or any number of household issues—what might normally be considered a simple battery or assault can become a domestic violence charge — but only if certain conditions are met.

For roommates to fall under Florida’s domestic violence statute, they must have “resided together as a family unit.” This doesn’t require a romantic relationship or blood relation. Courts look at factors such as:

  • Duration of cohabitation: How long have you lived together?
  • Shared responsibilities: Do you split household duties, bills, or expenses?
  • Interdependence: Do you rely on each other for transportation, childcare, or other needs?
  • Presentation to others: Do you present yourselves as a household unit to neighbors, landlords, or others?

Extended Family Situations

These charges also commonly arise in multigenerational households where adult children live with parents, or when extended family members share a home. The stress of multiple adults with different lifestyles, schedules, and expectations living under one roof can sometimes lead to conflicts that escalate into physical confrontations.

The Emotional Complexity

What makes these cases particularly challenging is the ongoing relationship dynamic. Unlike stranger-on-stranger violence, these situations involve people who must continue living together or seeing each other regularly. The alleged victim may feel pressure to minimize the incident or may have mixed feelings about pursuing charges, while the accused often feels betrayed by someone they trusted.Fort Lauderdale domestic violence lawyer

How These Cases Differ from Typical Domestic Violence Cases

Relationship Dynamics

Traditional domestic violence cases typically involve intimate partners with complex emotional histories, potential financial dependence, and often patterns of control or abuse. The relationship itself is central to understanding the alleged crime.

Roommate/family member cases often stem from practical disputes rather than relationship control issues. The underlying conflict might be about household responsibilities, personal space, or lifestyle differences rather than power and control within an intimate relationship.

Evidence and Witness Challenges

In roommate situations, there are often more potential witnesses since multiple people may live in the home. However, these witnesses may be reluctant to get involved in what they see as a “roommate dispute” rather than serious criminal conduct.

The physical evidence may also be different. While intimate partner violence often occurs in private spaces, roommate conflicts might happen in common areas where evidence is more readily apparent to others.

Prosecution Approach

Continue reading

Contact Information
Broward
800 SE 3rd Ave
#410
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33316
Phone: (954) 761-4011
Palm Beach
500 S Australian Ave #638
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Miami-Dade*
121 Alhambra Plaza #1500
Coral Gables, FL 33134
*By Appointment Only
3025 N Ocean Blvd #101
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33308
Phone: (954) 761-3641

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Please do not include any confidential or sensitive information in a contact form, text message, or voicemail. The contact form sends information by non-encrypted email, which is not secure. Submitting a contact form, sending a text message, making a phone call, or leaving a voicemail does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Copyright © 2025, The Ansara Law Firm
JUSTIA Law Firm Blog Design